The Reenactment

A film crew working on an Unsolved Mysteries-type-show (Myths & Mysteries) in the mid-90s gets more than they bargained for when they arrive to film at an abandoned house, only to find out it may not be abandoned after all. The story goes that a couple of bank robbers known as the Wallach Brothers once used this house as their safe house. Unbeknownst to them, it had been recently sold to a young newlywed couple, who ended up spending their first night alone in their new home at precisely the wrong time. The bank robbers arrived at the house to lay low after another successful robbery, and brutally murdered the couple they weren't expecting to be there. Afterwards, the Wallach Brothers disappeared. What happened to the bank robbers has been a mystery ever since. And some mysteries, it turns out, are better left unsolved.